The “Woke 3.0” memes the day after the midterms were hilarious, but they also got me thinking about what change we’d actually see from this blue wave in the media world. Are we going to see media companies that rolled back their DEI support start singing a different tune and finally address some of the elephants in the room, like the way Hollywood has been pushing women out of C-suite roles?

While the Trump administration has stepped on the gas when it comes to dismantling diversity efforts, the retreat from DEI has been happening in the shadows for years now. After many companies made sweeping DEI commitments in 2020, a report from The Washington Post a couple years back showed that many of them were already cutting their DEI teams by early 2024. And zooming in on just media, California lawmakers had raised questions as early as 2023 about why so many Black women executives were leaving Hollywood.

There’s a big question mark on what comes after the midterms, and I wanted to hear what media leaders and notable journalists who’ve done some incredible work in the diversity and inclusion space had to say about this question:

After watching media companies roll back DEI initiatives and retreat from the commitments they made in 2020, what do you think it will actually take for this political momentum to translate into a meaningful ideological shift in the media industry?

A special thank you to everyone who contributed to this story for their candor, wisdom and clarity. Here’s what they had to say:

S. Mitra Kalita, CEO of URL Media and publisher of Epicenter NYC

DEI is clearly not dead. You can try to cancel a program, but you cannot cancel a people. My colleagues in the media industry, as much as I stand in solidarity with them, have been slipping in their commitment to equity and inclusion over the last few years. I see pictures of all-white panels, newsrooms, and the like on the regular now. This will not bode well for businesses rooted not just in representation but in markets. Black and brown people are not just voters but we are customers and consumers. You rolled us back at your peril.  

Kirsten Schaffer, CEO of WIF

Lasting change in this industry doesn’t come from an election cycle or a social media moment. It comes from sustained commitment, and that’s exactly what we’re seeing some companies walk away from. The promises made in 2020 were meant to be a turning point, not a trend. Performative quotas and one-off initiatives won’t get us there. What will is investing in equitable systems: opening doors to hiring and greenlighting, nurturing talent, and creating real opportunities for women, people of color, gender-diverse people, and all underrepresented creators. The numbers show what’s at stake. Only nine of the top 100 films last year had a woman director. When we put diverse voices at the center of storytelling, the stories are richer, they resonate with audiences, and they last. That’s the case we’ll keep making to studios and to the industry at large.

Versha Sharma, founder of Fine Lines and former editor in chief of Teen Vogue

It's honestly really disappointing that so many media companies cowered in the face of Trump 2.0 so early into his administration — when as the midterms showed us, that doesn't reflect the popular will of the public (and therefore our audiences and consumers) at all. I was talking to Karen Attiah about it, and this was just days after the midterm results as well as days after she went public with her decision not to return to The Washington Post after winning her case against them. She said, "Given what happened with the midterms, it's malpractice not to have Black or Latino people there [in a newsroom] to help explain the blue wave." I completely agree, and I also completely support her decision not to return to the Post. Corporate media and establishment outlets have shown they don't value us again and again. It's time to build new institutions because I'm not holding my breath for a "meaningful ideological shift in the media industry." Even post-midterms, we see too much breathless analysis from white power brokers about Bari Weiss, CBS, CNN, Skydance, with no questioning about how they missed the blue wave, and I'm tired of waiting for them to catch up. If you want to help me build something new, please get in touch!

Noella Williams, culture journalist

Unlike the early 2020s, I don't know if I'm seeking accountability from traditional publications that replace their marginalized employees with white people or heavily censor their remaining non-white employees. I shudder while looking at the mastheads of some of these companies that were allegedly committed to DEI initiatives, not to mention that the Freelance Solidarity Project from The National Writers Union confirms any suspicions I have about how freelancers are treated. I often sing praises of worker-owned media and independent publications as a method of restoring my faith in the industry, because I've lost a lot of hope in the folks who were quick to adapt to Trump's administration and fall short on their commitments.

Sidney Madden, director of ‘And Counting’ and journalist 

The thing about a wave is it crashes and it ends, just as it begins again. So in that sense, I think of this struggle as a continuum. To ensure this "blue wave" of good energy and Democratic political momentum gives way to lasting change and a meaningful shift in the media industry, there needs to be a federal reinforcement of DEI programs at an impenetrable level and a change in leadership at most major companies with people who won't be scared to live their virtues even when those virtues get tested.

Lara Witt, editor in chief of Prism 

Part of why it was so easy to roll back DEI initiatives was that media companies were never actually committed to structural changes, and while aspects of DEI are admirable, they remain a watered-down version of the kind of radical change that is required of us to make ideological shifts that result in deeply rooted and meaningful political changes. DEI does not go far enough because of its built-in and intentional limitations—DEI is equality for us within inherently oppressive structures as opposed to a dismantling of the systems themselves.

I don’t believe that for-profit media companies will ever be incentivized to make meaningful strides towards journalism and building bottom-up cultures that benefit marginalized people if their commitments are geared towards profits and reflecting a political status quo that maintains capitalism and racial and gendered inequities. Legacy media has traditionally seen progressive politicians as a threat and are biased against agendas that are left-leaning. This is particularly true as we see our media bought up by billionaires and as newsrooms charge forward with AI tools over improving working conditions for newsroom staff. 

I believe it would take a consumer shift towards the kind of journalism that the members of the Movement Media Alliance are building and the kind of work that Prism Reports does. 

Reply

Avatar

or to participate